What the score is based on
We use three kinds of evidence:
- The operator’s own rules: terms, bonus rules, payment pages and game rules.
- Registers and technical documents: regulators’ license registers, provider documentation, audit statements and protocol descriptions.
- Independent reports: repeated, dated reports on complaint sites and gambling forums that the operator does not control.
Some checks also use what anyone can see on the casino’s public pages, such as the game catalog, search and sign-up requirements. For support checks we may also send a question to the casino without making a deposit.
We do not deposit, play or withdraw. Withdrawal times on our site are always the time the operator states, and player reports about timing are shown separately and are not a measurement.
The eight criteria and their weights
| Criterion | Weight | What it looks at |
|---|---|---|
| Withdrawal terms and reports | 25% | Payout reports, stated time frame, limits, fees, response to disputes |
| Safety and license | 20% | License and domain, operator identity, account protection, KYC clarity, incidents |
| Bonus terms | 15% | Wagering, cash-out limits, maximum bet and game contribution, who can claim, conflicting terms |
| Game fairness | 10% | Game rules, RTP sources, audits, provably fair protocol, game versions |
| Crypto payments | 10% | Coin and network pairs, fees, minimums, conversion, confirmations and failures |
| Games | 10% | Catalog, search, filters, provider details, game categories |
| Support | 5% | Channels, reply time, accuracy, escalation, ticket history |
| Usability | 5% | Mobile use, sign-up clarity, how easily terms can be found, cashier instructions, keyboard access |
How points become a score
Each criterion has five checks, and each check gets 0, 1 or 2 points. Zero means the requirement is confirmed as not met, 1 means partly met and 2 means fully met. That gives each criterion a result from 0 to 10.
The checklist result is the sum of each criterion’s result multiplied by its weight. We apply any caps, then round to one decimal place once, at the end. The commission a casino pays is not an input in this calculation.
An unknown answer stays unknown. We never count it as 1 point, and we never work out a score from only the checks we could complete. Until every check is filled in, the review shows no checklist result, and the facts we do have stay visible.
The score in lists and at the top of each review is the editorial score. Our team sets it with the checklist as its basis. Where the checklist is complete, its result and breakdown appear in the review next to it.
Worked example
| Criterion | Weight | Result out of 10 | Adds to score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Withdrawal terms and reports | 25% | 8 | 2.00 |
| Safety and license | 20% | 7 | 1.40 |
| Bonus terms | 15% | 6 | 0.90 |
| Game fairness | 10% | 7 | 0.70 |
| Crypto payments | 10% | 9 | 0.90 |
| Games | 10% | 8 | 0.80 |
| Support | 5% | 6 | 0.30 |
| Usability | 5% | 8 | 0.40 |
| Final score | 100% | 7.4 (Fair) |
An invented casino, shown only to explain the arithmetic. With an unconfirmed license the same casino’s checklist result would be capped at 7.0. With confirmed systematic withholding of funds it would be capped at 4.9 (Avoid).
What the score labels mean
| Score | Label |
|---|---|
| 9.0 to 10 | Excellent |
| 8.0 to 8.9 | Very good |
| 6.5 to 7.9 | Fair |
| 5.0 to 6.4 | Caution |
| 0 to 4.9 | Avoid |
The label always appears next to the number. A small gap between two scores does not mean one casino is clearly better.
Checklist caps and statuses
| Situation | What happens on the site |
|---|---|
| Fewer than 3 independent sources | No checklist result; the review notes the missing sources |
| License not confirmed | Checklist result capped at 7.0; visible warning in the review |
| Serious payout dispute | Status Under review; new recommendations and casino links paused until there is an outcome |
| Confirmed fake license | Status Blacklisted; no casino links; evidence and a review procedure |
| Confirmed systematic withholding of funds | Status Blacklisted; checklist result capped at 4.9; no casino links |
| Casino closed | Status Closed; no offer; closure date and alternatives |
One complaint about a missing payout is not an accusation of fraud. We record the source, the conditions, the operator’s reply and the outcome.
What confirmed means
When we say a serious problem is confirmed, we mean it rests on at least three independent sources or on a document, such as a regulator’s decision. Casinos with confirmed serious problems are listed on our blacklist with the grounds and a way to ask for a review.
Casinos with no bonus
| Criterion | Normal weight | Weight with no bonus |
|---|---|---|
| Withdrawal terms and reports | 25% | 29.4% |
| Safety and license | 20% | 23.5% |
| Bonus terms | 15% | Not applicable |
| Game fairness | 10% | 11.8% |
| Crypto payments | 10% | 11.8% |
| Games | 10% | 11.8% |
| Support | 5% | 5.9% |
| Usability | 5% | 5.9% |
This applies only when the rules and cashier confirm the operator offers no bonus and has no hidden promotional conditions. Each remaining weight is divided by 0.85. A casino with no bonus cannot appear in a best-bonus list.
How we use independent sources
- A score needs at least three different independent sites, and at least one of them must carry complaints or be a forum.
- Two records from the same site count as one source.
- The operator’s own site and advertising never count as independent.
- A site that earns from links to the operator may be counted, but it cannot be the only basis for a conclusion.
- One review proves little. We look for repeated, dated reports, and we set aside doubtful reviews and batches of near-identical messages.
- For the first withdrawal check, reports older than 12 months do not count.
Reviews can be bought, and many review sites earn from casino links. That is why we do not treat positive reviews as proof that an operator is reliable. On review pages you will see our own short summary and the date of the check. Our editorial policy explains why.
The full rubric
These are the 40 checks. Some use the operator’s rules, some use registers and some use independent reports. Where a casino has no provably fair games, check F4 uses a relevant audit instead.
Withdrawal terms and reports (25%)
| ID | 2 points | 1 point | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| W1 | Sources show payouts are made; no unresolved non-payment disputes in the last 12 months | Isolated unresolved disputes | Systematic refusal to pay confirmed in at least three independent sources |
| W2 | The time frame is in the rules and reports do not contradict it | The time frame is stated, but some reports describe delays | No time frame stated, or widespread reports contradict it |
| W3 | Minimum, maximum, period and exceptions are published before sign-up | Some limits can only be found through support or after sign-up | A material limit is hidden or contradictory |
| W4 | All fees are published and reports do not contradict them | Fees are only partly confirmed | Repeated reports of undeclared charges |
| W5 | The operator answers complaints on independent sites and a dispute process is described | It does not always answer, or the process is only partly described | Complaints are ignored and there is no process |
Safety and license (20%)
| ID | 2 points | 1 point | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| S1 | An active license and the domain are confirmed in the register | The license holder is confirmed, but domain coverage needs clarifying | The license is confirmed as fake, revoked or not applicable |
| S2 | Operator, legal entity, address and rules all match | The operator is identified, but some details are incomplete | Hidden or contradictory identity is confirmed |
| S3 | Two-factor login and session control are described in the documentation | One of the two is described | Documentation and support confirm that neither exists |
| S4 | KYC triggers, data and process are described and reports do not contradict them | The basics are described and some details came from support | Repeated reports of demands at withdrawal with no basis in the rules |
| S5 | For the last 12 months there are checkable outcomes for incidents found, or a documented search found none | Outcomes are partial and the open risk is disclosed | A confirmed serious incident remains unresolved |
Bonus terms (15%)
| ID | 2 points | 1 point | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| B1 | Wagering, its base and its time limit are clear | One element had to be obtained from support | The base or the multiplier is materially contradictory |
| B2 | Cash-out limits and exclusions are visible before activation | They only appear at the final step | A hidden restriction is confirmed |
| B3 | Maximum bet, game contribution and exclusions are listed in the rules | Some of this was only available on request | Material restrictions are hidden |
| B4 | Countries, coins and audience are clear | One condition needs clarifying | An offer is shown to an audience it does not apply to |
| B5 | The promo page and the full rules match | A minor difference was found | There is a material conflict between them |
Game fairness (10%)
| ID | 2 points | 1 point | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| F1 | Rules for the three selected games are published | Rules are visible only inside the game | Material rules are missing |
| F2 | RTP and version of the three games are confirmed by the rules | Only the provider’s reference RTP is known | The displayed RTP contradicts the rules |
| F3 | The claimed audit and its scope are confirmed by a source | The audit is confirmed, but its scope is incomplete | The audit claim is disproved |
| F4 | The provably fair protocol is described and an independent source confirms it can be reproduced; for other games, a relevant audit is confirmed | The protocol is described with no independent confirmation | The mechanism is claimed without a description, or is disproved |
| F5 | Versions and the parameters that apply to them are stated clearly | The version was established through support | Mixing of incompatible versions without disclosure is proven |
Crypto payments (10%)
| ID | 2 points | 1 point | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| P1 | Coin and network pairs are published for deposits and withdrawals | Only some directions are published | Reports show a listed network does not work in practice |
| P2 | Operator fees and network fees are separated in the rules | The total is known, but what makes it up is partly unclear | Repeated reports of a hidden fee |
| P3 | Minimums and maximums are published | Some can only be found through support | A material limit is not disclosed |
| P4 | The balance unit and conversion rules are described | They are partly described | Reports of funds being converted without notice |
| P5 | Confirmations, memo requirements and failures are described | Some of this is only available through support | A critical instruction is missing |
Games (10%)
| ID | 2 points | 1 point | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| G1 | Three selected games appear in the public catalog | Two of the three appear | The games the casino advertises are mostly missing |
| G2 | Public search finds the three selected titles | It finds some, or only through the provider | There is no public search |
| G3 | Filters for game type and provider work | One main filter works | Main filters are missing or do not work |
| G4 | The provider and rules of the three games can be identified | Some details need clarifying | Missing information on game origin is confirmed |
| G5 | At least three confirmed categories and a clear catalog | One or two categories with a clear focus | The advertised range materially differs from the catalog |
Support (5%)
| ID | 2 points | 1 point | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | Live and non-live channels are listed and reports confirm they work | One channel is confirmed | Reports show the listed channels do not work |
| C2 | Reports, or our own question sent without a deposit: a reply within 15 minutes on live chat or 24 hours by email | A reply within 48 hours | No reply after 48 hours |
| C3 | Answers to our question on network, KYC and limits are correct | Two of the three are correct | An instruction is materially wrong |
| C4 | Escalation is described and reports confirm it | It is described but not confirmed | Reports show no working process |
| C5 | Ticket history and ticket numbers are described | One of the two is described | Neither is described |
Usability (5%)
| ID | 2 points | 1 point | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| U1 | The public site works on desktop and mobile | There are non-critical obstacles on mobile | The public site does not work on mobile |
| U2 | Sign-up shows its requirements clearly | Some requirements appear later, before the deposit | Sign-up promises contradict mandatory requirements |
| U3 | Terms, KYC rules and limits can be reached in two clicks | It takes three or four clicks | Key rules cannot be found even after searching and asking |
| U4 | Cashier instructions show the coin, network, address and amount | They are partly described, without ambiguity | Dangerous ambiguity about the network or amount |
| U5 | The public site works by keyboard, with labels and visible focus | Some of these are partly missing | Main pages cannot be used by keyboard |
Words we use carefully
| Word | What it means on this site |
|---|---|
| No KYC | The operator’s rules do not require documents in the stated scenario and reports do not contradict that. Extra checks may still happen, and we say so. |
| Fast withdrawal | A stated time of up to 1 hour and no repeated delay reports in the last 180 days. It is always labeled as a stated time. |
| Instant | We use it only when quoting an operator’s claim, not as our own finding. |
| Safe | We do not call a casino safe as a general promise. We describe the specific license, rules and reports. |
| Accepted | The operator’s rules accept players from that location. This is not a legal opinion, and a site being reachable does not make it legal. |
| Checked | We compared the fact with the named type of source on the date shown. It does not mean we moved funds. |
How lists and rankings are built
A casino list first removes casinos that are unavailable or unconfirmed, then applies the topic of the list, then sorts by editorial score. If two casinos show the same score, the one with the more recent check comes first.
The site has no editor’s picks or paid placements at present. If we add them, each must sit apart from the numbered ranking: a pick with a stated reason, a paid placement labeled as sponsored. How We Make Money has the details.
Rechecks and versions
Independent sources are rechecked every 90 days for the top 20 casinos and every 180 days for other rated casinos. After that date there is a 14-day window with a visible warning, and then the casino leaves recommendation lists. Its review stays online.
Review pages show the score, the date of the source check, the date of the assessment and the methodology version. A published assessment is not edited afterwards. If the weights change, we publish a new version and reassess casinos under it. Old scores are not silently recalculated.
The limits of this method
- We do not make deposits or withdrawals, so we cannot report first-hand payout times.
- Players who had problems are more likely to post than players who did not, and some reports cannot be traced to a real account.
- Operators can change their rules between our checks. The rules on the casino’s site always take priority over our summary.
- The method does not tell you whether gambling is legal in your state or country.
If you think a fact or a score is wrong, send us the page and your source.